
Urban Cowboy Lodge
Best for adults who want on-site nightlife, a larger set of amenities and organized spa/sauna experiences.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is a larger, adults-only Catskills resort in Big Indian with multiple bars, seasonal pool, sauna and on-site spa services — read this if you want an active, design-forward adult getaway. The Yarra is an upscale boutique inn in Roscoe with four guestrooms and a strong guest rating — read this if you prefer a small, quiet inn near Catskill State Park.
Updated

Best for adults who want on-site nightlife, a larger set of amenities and organized spa/sauna experiences.

Best for travelers who want a quiet, small-inn stay steps from Catskill State Park and a complimentary continental breakfast.
When Urban Cowboy Lodge wins: pick Urban Cowboy if you want an adults-only property with multiple bars, more on-site recreation (sauna, seasonal pool, game room, bowling), and a larger room roster for variety and event hosting.
When The Yarra wins: choose The Yarra if you prefer a tiny, upscale boutique inn in Roscoe with very high guest ratings, a simple included breakfast, and immediate access to Catskill State Park.
Bottom line: Urban Cowboy is the choice for couples or groups seeking an active adults-only resort experience with more on-site services; The Yarra is the quieter option for travelers after a compact, highly rated inn close to park trails.
| Category | Urban Cowboy Lodge | The Yarra |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-forward adults-only mountain lodge with social bars and resort amenities | Quiet, upscale boutique inn with a small number of rooms |
| Location | Big Indian, along Esopus Creek in the Catskills | Roscoe, a short walk to Catskill State Park |
| Size (guest rooms) | 42 unique rooms (property lists 28–42 in sources) across multiple buildings | 4 air-conditioned guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (18+; some sources list 21+ minimum) | All ages welcome |
| Pools / bathing | Seasonal outdoor swimming pool; on-property sauna and spring-fed swimming hole mentioned | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Dining Room (New American) plus Parlor Bar and Ralph's Bar & Bowling | One on-site restaurant; complimentary continental breakfast daily |
| Spa / wellness | On-request spa services and bookable Estonian sauna sessions | Not published |
| Known for | Adults-only lodge experience, farm-to-table dining and creekside/Catskills access | Upscale boutique feel and very high guest rating near park trails |
| Parking | Free self-parking on site | |
| Breakfast | Restaurant brunch offered (The Dining Room); no all-inclusive meal plan | Complimentary continental breakfast served daily 7:00–11:00 AM |
| Wi‑Fi | Free Wi‑Fi across property (note: limited cell service on site) | |
Urban Cowboy Lodge sits along Esopus Creek in Big Indian with direct access to Catskills trails and nearby Belleayre Mountain.
Choose Urban Cowboy for a creekside Catskills base with quick trail access and drive-in convenience.
The Yarra is in Roscoe, a short walk from Catskill State Park and local fly-fishing and nature sites.
Pick The Yarra if you want immediate access to park trails and a quieter, village setting.
Urban Cowboy offers many room types and suite configurations across several buildings.
Urban Cowboy is better if you want choices in room size and features — especially if you want a tub or suite layout.
The Yarra has four air-conditioned guestrooms in classic boutique-inn fashion.
The Yarra suits travelers who prefer a compact, carefully tended set of rooms rather than many choices.
Urban Cowboy provides full-service dining and several on-site bars for evening life.
Go to Urban Cowboy when you want an on-property restaurant program and nightlife options.
The Yarra offers a single on-site restaurant and complimentary continental breakfast.
The Yarra is best for travelers who prefer a calm dining experience and included breakfast.
Urban Cowboy lists a seasonal outdoor swimming pool plus other water or bathing options.
Urban Cowboy is the better pick if a pool or curated sauna experience matters.
The Yarra’s listing does not publish a pool or on-site wellness pool.
Expect outdoor trail access rather than hotel pool amenities at The Yarra.
Urban Cowboy combines a wellness program (sauna, spa treatments) with evening bars and entertainment.
Urban Cowboy mixes wellness and social options for guests who want both relaxation and evening life.
The Yarra presents a quiet, small-inn experience with limited published nightlife or spa offerings.
The Yarra is a low-key choice for travelers prioritizing quiet and nearby nature over on-site wellness and nightlife.

Urban Cowboy — explicitly adults-only with an adults-focused program, bars and romantic packages.

The Yarra — four-room upscale inn a 1-minute walk from Catskill State Park.

Urban Cowboy — full-service restaurant plus multiple bars including a bowling bar.

The Yarra — strong guest rating and a calm, small-inn environment with complimentary breakfast.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is adults-only; The Yarra welcomes guests of all ages.
Urban Cowboy has an Estonian sauna and on-request spa treatments; The Yarra’s listing does not publish a spa.
Both properties are well placed for outdoor access, but Urban Cowboy advertises immediate access to Giant Ledge, Slide Mountain and other Big Indian trailheads while The Yarra is a short walk to Catskill State Park.
The Yarra includes a complimentary continental breakfast; Urban Cowboy offers a full-service brunch/dinner restaurant but does not include meals by default.
Explore how Urban Cowboy Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·