
Urban Cowboy Lodge
Best for adults looking for a full-service Catskills lodge with spa services, multiple on-site dining/drink options, and seasonal pool access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is an adults-only, design-forward Catskills lodge in Big Indian with on-site dining, a sauna/spa program, and a seasonal outdoor pool — read this if you want a grown-up lodge escape with full-service amenities. Antrim Streamside is a small cabin-and-lodge style retreat on the water in Livingston Manor that suits travelers who want simple, streamside rooms, free continental breakfast, and easy access to Catskill State Park.
Updated

Best for adults looking for a full-service Catskills lodge with spa services, multiple on-site dining/drink options, and seasonal pool access.

Best for travelers who want simple, rustic-luxe cottage or house options right on the water with included continental breakfast and easy access to fishing and state-park trails.
When Urban Cowboy Lodge wins: choose Urban Cowboy if you want an adults-only property with on-site farm-to-table dining, a dedicated sauna and spa treatments, more on-property activities (game room, bowling, events), and a more developed hospitality program.
When Antrim Streamside wins: pick Antrim Streamside if you prioritize direct waterfront/stream access, a quieter small-property feel, included continental breakfast, lower-key cabin-style rooms (Luxury Cottage / Luxury House options), and easy fishing or tubing nearby.
Bottom line: Urban Cowboy is the choice for a full-service, adults-focused Catskills lodge experience; Antrim Streamside is the practical pick for an intimate, streamside stay in Livingston Manor with simple comforts and outdoor access.
| Category | Urban Cowboy Lodge | Antrim Streamside |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Adults-only mountain lodge with curated public spaces, sauna/spa, and seasonal pool | Small streamside cabin-and-lodge retreat focused on water, woods, and low-key comfort |
| Location | Big Indian, along Esopus Creek and near Giant Ledge and Belleayre area | Livingston Manor waterfront, steps from Catskill State Park and near Catskill Brewery |
| Size / rooms | Multiple buildings; marketed as 28–42 rooms depending on source; many room types and suites | 6 guestrooms (room types include Luxury Cottage and Luxury House, river and mountain views) |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (no guests under 18; minimum check-in age enforced) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools / water access | Seasonal outdoor swimming pool plus on-site spring-fed swimming hole and Esopus Creek frontage | Walkway to water/streamside setting; water tubing and fishing nearby |
| Restaurants & bars | The Dining Room (seasonal farm-to-table American) plus Parlor Bar and additional bars/venues | No signature restaurant listed; complimentary continental breakfast daily |
| Wellness / spa | Sauna (bookable private sessions) and on-request spa/massage treatments | No dedicated spa listed; simple in-room amenities (robes) and outdoor-focused activities |
| Known for | Adults-only lodge experience, curated dining/drinks, events and wedding hosting, soaking tubs | Streamside cottages, complimentary breakfast, fishing/tubing access and free parking |
| Pet policy | Pet friendly (dogs allowed; check property for details) | Pets allowed in specific rooms for a fee (pet fee applies; service animals exempt) |
| Front desk & service | Front desk with limited hours; arrival time should be communicated in advance | Front desk staffed during limited hours (9:00 AM–5:00 PM noted) |
Urban Cowboy Lodge sits along Esopus Creek in Big Indian, inside the Catskill Park and near popular hikes and Belleayre Mountain.
Choose Urban Cowboy for creekside mountain access with more developed lodge infrastructure and easy drive-to outdoor options.
Antrim Streamside is a small waterfront property in Livingston Manor, a short drive from Catskill Brewery and local trailheads.
Pick Antrim Streamside if you want a compact, water-focused base in Livingston Manor with immediate stream access.
Urban Cowboy offers many distinct room types across several buildings, from cabins to suites with soaking tubs.
Urban Cowboy is for guests who want room variety, design-forward details, and rooms geared to adult comfort.
Antrim Streamside has six guestrooms in cottage/house formats with basics like refrigerators and microwaves.
Antrim Streamside suits travelers who want simple, streamside cottages with practical in-room conveniences.
Urban Cowboy centers dining around The Dining Room (seasonal farm-to-table) and several on-site bars.
Urban Cowboy is for travelers who want on-site, chef-led meals and evening bar options without leaving property.
Antrim Streamside provides a complimentary continental breakfast and a low-key, self-directed food setup.
Antrim Streamside works if you prefer quick included breakfast and plan to eat out locally or self-cater.
Urban Cowboy lists a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and creek frontage plus a noted spring-fed swimming hole on property.
For multiple water experiences (pool plus creek/swimming hole), Urban Cowboy provides more varied options.
Antrim Streamside is focused on immediate stream/river access and nearby tubing/fishing opportunities.
Antrim Streamside is the pick if you want to be literally steps from the water for fishing or tubing rather than a developed pool.
Urban Cowboy offers a bookable Estonian sauna, on-request massage treatments, and lively evening spaces like bars and a bowling venue.
If you want scheduled wellness services plus evening bar entertainment at one property, Urban Cowboy covers both.
Antrim Streamside does not list a spa or sauna; its draw is quiet outdoor time and basic communal spaces.
Antrim Streamside is for travelers who prefer outdoor-focused relaxation rather than on-site spa services or evening bar scenes.

Urban Cowboy — on-site seasonal pool, sauna and bookable spa treatments, restaurant and bars, and adults-only policy.

Antrim Streamside — direct waterfront access, fishing and tubing nearby, and included continental breakfast.

Antrim Streamside — compact property with practical room amenities and free continental breakfast.

Urban Cowboy — The Dining Room, Parlor Bar, Ralph's Bar & Bowling, and an event program for groups.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is adults-only (no guests under 18). Antrim Streamside is not adults-only.
Urban Cowboy offers a bookable sauna and on-request massage treatments. Antrim Streamside does not list a spa.
Antrim Streamside offers a complimentary continental breakfast daily. Urban Cowboy has on-site dining but does not include breakfast as a standard free offering in the same way.
Antrim Streamside places you steps from the water for fishing and tubing; Urban Cowboy provides a seasonal pool plus creek frontage and nearby natural swimming holes.
Explore how Urban Cowboy Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·