
Urban Cowboy Lodge
Best for adults looking for a full-service, design-forward lodge with on-site restaurant, sauna and seasonal pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is an adults-only Catskills lodge in Big Indian with on-site dining, sauna/spa services, and creekside outdoor activities. Stonehill's Farmhouse is a boutique farmhouse-style lodging in Accord for travelers who want small, countryside rooms close to Minnewaska and local farms.
Updated

Best for adults looking for a full-service, design-forward lodge with on-site restaurant, sauna and seasonal pool.

Best for travelers seeking a small farmhouse stay in Accord near Arrowood Farms and Minnewaska State Park.
When Urban Cowboy Lodge wins: choose Urban Cowboy if you want an adults-only stay with multiple on-site dining/drink options, booked spa treatments and creekside activities on a larger lodge property.
When Stonehill's Farmhouse wins: pick Stonehill's Farmhouse if you prefer a smaller, farmhouse-style B&B in Accord with easy access to local farms, Minnewaska State Park, and a café/bar on site.
Bottom line: Urban Cowboy is the fuller-service adults-only resort for a grown-up weekend with dining, sauna and a seasonal pool; Stonehill's Farmhouse is a quieter, smaller farmhouse option for visitors focused on nearby Hudson Valley sites.
| Category | Urban Cowboy Lodge | Stonehill's Farmhouse |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-forward adults-only mountain lodge with creek frontage and multiple guest services | Boutique farmhouse-style bed & breakfast with individually decorated guestrooms |
| Location | Big Indian, along Esopus Creek in the Catskills | Accord, in the Hudson Valley near Arrowood Farms and Minnewaska State Park |
| Size | Multiple buildings; 28 rooms (property statements vary by listing) | Small B&B with 4 individually decorated guestrooms plus additional cabins/suites listed |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (no guests under 18; check-in age enforced) | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools / swimming | Seasonal outdoor swimming pool; also described as having spring-fed swimming hole on property | Swimming available nearby (no on-site pool listed) |
| Restaurants & bars | The Dining Room (seasonal farm-to-table) plus Parlor Bar and other on-site outlets | Farmhouse Tavern café with bar/lounge and a coffee shop/cafe on site |
| Spa & wellness | On-request spa services and an Estonian sauna (bookable sessions) | Sauna listed among amenities; massage/spa not explicitly listed |
| Known for | Adults-only lodge experience, creekside grounds, on-site dining and event hosting | Farmhouse lodging, Farmhouse Tavern, proximity to Arrowood Farms and Minnewaska |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking; limited front-desk hours, arrival notice recommended | Free self-parking and off-street parking; self check-in procedures and smart locks noted |
| Family / groups | Not for children; adults-only weddings and events | Family suites and cabins listed; accommodates families and groups |
Urban Cowboy sits on creekside property in Big Indian, placing guests near Catskills hiking and Belleayre Mountain.
Urban Cowboy is better if you want close access to Catskills hikes and creekside scenery.
Stonehill's Farmhouse is located in Accord with short drives to Arrowood Farms and Minnewaska State Park.
Stonehill's works well for visitors prioritizing the Accord/Hudson Valley sightseeing circuit.
Urban Cowboy offers multiple room types across several buildings including cabins and suites.
Choose Urban Cowboy for a wider selection of adult-focused room types and specialty suites.
Stonehill's lists a range of rooms and cabins that emphasize farmhouse character.
Stonehill's is a smaller-scale stay with farmhouse-style rooms and some cabin options.
Urban Cowboy centers dining around The Dining Room plus Parlor Bar and other casual outlets.
Urban Cowboy suits travelers who want an integrated restaurant and bar scene on property.
Stonehill's offers the Farmhouse Tavern café/bar plus a coffee shop/café for casual meals.
Stonehill's works for guests who prefer a small on-site café/tavern and nearby farm-to-table options.
Urban Cowboy lists a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and creekside swimming hole as guest options.
Urban Cowboy is the better pick if you plan to use an on-site pool and creek-based recreation.
Stonehill's highlights a garden, picnic area and nearby swimming opportunities.
Stonehill's is good for low-key outdoor relaxation and access to nearby natural swimming spots.
Urban Cowboy provides an Estonian sauna, bookable spa treatments and multiple on-site bars.
Urban Cowboy is aimed at adults who want spa bookings plus lively bar and small-venue nightlife on property.
Stonehill's lists a sauna and a bar/lounge at Farmhouse Tavern; nightlife beyond the property is local and low-key.
Stonehill's suits travelers seeking modest wellness amenities and quieter evenings near Accord attractions.

Urban Cowboy — adults-only policy, on-site dining, sauna and seasonal pool make it ideal for grown-up escapes.

Stonehill's Farmhouse — farmhouse rooms, Farmhouse Tavern and close access to Minnewaska State Park.

Urban Cowboy — full restaurant program (The Dining Room), Parlor Bar and a second bar/bowling option on property.

Stonehill's Farmhouse — near Arrowood Farms and offers family suites and cabins in a farmhouse setting.
Urban Cowboy Lodge is adults-only and does not admit guests under 18. Stonehill's Farmhouse is not adults-only.
Both list sauna access; Urban Cowboy provides bookable spa services (massages and facials) on request. Stonehill's lists a sauna among amenities but does not publish a full spa program in the supplier listing.
Urban Cowboy has a more extensive on-site dining program (The Dining Room, Parlor Bar and additional outlets). Stonehill's offers Farmhouse Tavern and a coffee shop/cafe.
Urban Cowboy lists a seasonal outdoor pool and a spring-fed swimming hole on property. Stonehill's notes swimming nearby but no on-site pool is listed.
Explore how Urban Cowboy Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·